Skip to main content
replaced http://ux.stackexchange.com/ with https://ux.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Off topic questions:

I think this is on topic enough if you read the text of the question.

Not a real question:

There are 1 or 2 where I agree with you, they should be closed outright. But overall we're not doing too badly here (at least from my perspective).

Some of these questions are indeed borderline, but a trend I'm seeing here is that these questions can be whipped into shape by editing them to make them a bit more general.

So perhaps what you ought to consider doing in the future is contributing some edits -- as in the examples where I edited, above -- to help make the questions better for everyone!

Off topic questions:

I think this is on topic enough if you read the text of the question.

Not a real question:

There are 1 or 2 where I agree with you, they should be closed outright. But overall we're not doing too badly here (at least from my perspective).

Some of these questions are indeed borderline, but a trend I'm seeing here is that these questions can be whipped into shape by editing them to make them a bit more general.

So perhaps what you ought to consider doing in the future is contributing some edits -- as in the examples where I edited, above -- to help make the questions better for everyone!

Off topic questions:

I think this is on topic enough if you read the text of the question.

Not a real question:

There are 1 or 2 where I agree with you, they should be closed outright. But overall we're not doing too badly here (at least from my perspective).

Some of these questions are indeed borderline, but a trend I'm seeing here is that these questions can be whipped into shape by editing them to make them a bit more general.

So perhaps what you ought to consider doing in the future is contributing some edits -- as in the examples where I edited, above -- to help make the questions better for everyone!

Source Link
Jeff Atwood
  • 343
  • 1
  • 11

Off topic questions:

I think this is on topic enough if you read the text of the question.

Not a real question:

There are 1 or 2 where I agree with you, they should be closed outright. But overall we're not doing too badly here (at least from my perspective).

Some of these questions are indeed borderline, but a trend I'm seeing here is that these questions can be whipped into shape by editing them to make them a bit more general.

So perhaps what you ought to consider doing in the future is contributing some edits -- as in the examples where I edited, above -- to help make the questions better for everyone!