3

The new feature of [on hold] instead of [close] is great, but maybe it's not fully implemented yet. As of now, we put questions on hold to encourage editing, but when the question should be nominated for not being on hold, we call it reopen. Is there a specific reason for this or is it just a labeling mistake?

reopen voting

Reference question: What is the purpose and origin of in-page navigation

  • 2
    So, I guess my question back to you would be - what should the option be called? 'un-on-hold', 'de-hold', 're-activate'? I wouldn't be surprised if, having looked over the syntactical options, we end up back at 'well, reopen isn't too bad after all'. – JonW Jun 26 '13 at 9:43
  • LOL I agree to that @JonW, it might be the correct label. Still it feels wrong to reopen something that isn't closed. Looking at suggestions doesn't give the proper meaning either "advanced, forwarded, furthered, hastened, hurried". If i had to chose, it would be simply activate since on hold is also inactive. The community may have a better label, let's ask them of an alternative?! – Benny Skogberg Jun 26 '13 at 11:11
  • 1
    The label does matter but let's not forget what is actually happening: The question might be called “on hold” to encourage editing but it really is closed (can't be answered, will look like it was not a good question, etc.) so we need to act accordingly. – Gala Jul 10 '13 at 10:46
2

"On Hold" questions actually are closed, so it makes sense to be able to reopen them. "On Hold" means "Closed, but may be re-opened".

  • 1
    I could agree to that, that the questions are closed, but we call them something else to make them less frightning for new users. – Benny Skogberg Jul 29 '13 at 5:09
0

I think it is because we have not changed the labels. It is still 'close'/'close votes' and 'reopen'/'reopen votes'. Which, I think, should be changed everywhere too.

enter image description here

  • 2
    I don't really agree with changing the "close" button label. You're still voting that it should be be closed. There's just a "waiting period" before closure looks final now. – Ben Brocka Jun 26 '13 at 15:30
  • 1
    @BenBrocka Ah, ok. So it's Vote to close -> Hold -> Reopen and Vote to close -> Hold -> Closed -> Reopen – rk. Jun 26 '13 at 15:37
  • Yeah things will eventually convert to a "closed" state. The weirdness is the "reopen" verb doesn't match up with the present state of the "hold" question in a sense. Though it's still technically all the same thing; the only difference between "hold" and "closed" is how long it's been since the question was put on hold – Ben Brocka Jun 26 '13 at 15:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .