This is sort of a follow up to this question from a while ago: New custom close reason for shopping questions
However, that question took a bit of a turn into whether or not we replace any of our existing ones with a shopping request one. However my suggest is different.
Should we add an additional close reason for Shopping Requests? It's possible that the Stack Exchange team can add an additional close reason ontop of the 3 we currently have, should there be demand, desire and need for it.
Personally, I think yes. Judging by some questions from the past few months I think they would have benefited from being able to be closed specifically as a Shopping Request. Some of them were closed as 'implementation'. Some were closed as 'opinion based' and some as 'too broad' but none of those reasons are really accurate enough.
I already have a set comment I find myself using on shopping request questions when I close them which I feel may be appropriate to use as the close reason text:
Sorry, but questions requesting recommendations for tools / books / software / apps / papers etc. would fall into the shopping request category and aren't really suitable to a Q&A website. The reason for this is that there is no one correct answer, and such recommended items would soon be updated and replaced with newer / better versions making the best answers redundant.
So, what do we think? Would a new, specific Shopping Request close reason be needed, or do we already have the appropriate close reasons to make this unnecessary?
Here are some example questions from the past few months that I feel would've benefited from this close reason.