Saw this question: https://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/2566/web-application-u-i-critique
Is this the kind of question that we should have on the site?
Disregarding the fact that it is fairly subjective, I see it as an issue for a couple of other reasons. First of all, critiques aren't asking a specific question, which means that it is too broad to get a specific answer (even a subjective answer). Second, it is very "local" - it only really pertains to the user and their site; I don't think it's likely that someone else will stumble across that question and gain anything by reading its answers. Finally, this is akin to someone asking you to do work for them for free. As UI experts, shouldn't we get paid for doing critiques? :)