What is the policy around critique questions and how do we clarify it?
I did ask one a little while ago, but that related to a specific question I had been asked. I have another site, and, because of the responses from that one, I realise I don't have a particularly good eye, and would like insight. This is a personal one, so I cannot justify a formal assessment.
However, I don't want to cause trouble by asking for site assessments - it seems a little like the homework questions on SO. So would it be acceptable? What would the guidelines be?
And it would only be for comments on the UX, not for a full assessment of "does the site work".