9

Mods closed my first question as being too broad and when I asked different question (not merely rephrased the first one) they closed the second question too as being duplicate of the first one. They told me to modify the first question instead, which I did. They unblocked it then but left me with a question of -3 score with little chance of getting any attention of quality answer.

I find this procedure bit catch-22-like. What should I do? For clarity, I didn't come here to play games with mods, I came here for help.

| |
9

The mods (i.e. me) only put your first question on-hold as it was too broad. There was no mod intervention with the different question you asked - no mod has acted on that one. OK, it got a close vote against it but that wasn't from a mod but from a regular community member. It was also a community member who left a comment suggesting you edit your original question.

Your original question was then reopened by a mod (me) because you'd brought it inline with site requirements. That's a good thing (most people don't make an effort to improve on-hold questions).

So the main issue here is with the second question that you posted. To be honest, I wouldn't have had a problem with you asking that one as it's sufficiently different to the On Hold post that it could've existed in its own right. But I didn't notice it existed until you had deleted it yourself, and now we can't really reopen that one because that'd make two questions the same, both with different comments and questions.

So... I've undeleted your duplicate question and deleted the other one, merging the content between the two. That should get you back to 0 rep on it.

| |
  • 4
    Thanks. I don't want to be ungrateful, I know you provide the community a great service, for free. It's more about the tone SE uses to moderate users - it feels so disrespectful and patronizing. "This question has been .. blah blah". As UX enthusiasts you will maybe understand what I mean. – daniel.sedlacek Feb 26 '14 at 19:44
  • 2
    @daniel.sedlacek yes, some of the default messages that are applied to posts can be a bit harsh. Although they are better than they used to be. There never used to be an 'On Hold' status; everything just went to Closed or Deleted, so it's getting better. – JonW Feb 27 '14 at 0:22
  • There was a blog on SO about rephrasing those types of responses. Has that not flowed through to other SE sites? – tu-Reinstate Monica-dor duh Mar 12 '14 at 23:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .